Roborock Dyad vs. Tineco S5 Comparison Review

I have bought the Roborock Dyad because of the large battery; most cordless cleaners can only work for a maximum of 20 minutes. This model can clean my entire two-bedroom flat with one charge for 40 minutes. According to the manual, the maximum cleaning time is 43 minutes (300 sqm)! I also like how it is stored in the docking station; it cleans and dries its head roll. Honestly, it is enough to call my head roll 99% clean, especially from the tangled hair of my wife. Moreover, all dirt after cleaning stays in the tray; you need to clean it regularly.

For one clean, the water tank capacity is enough (900 ml); it can easily collect all coffee and juice spills, clean difficult stains, and accumulate all dirty water in a special tank – dirty tank (770 ml). The dirty and clean tank construction allows you to take them out quickly. But after one year of regular use, my dirty tank usually got stuck in its spot, and the dirty tank release button broke. Because of that, I usually have an indicator of a dirty tank full. After I take it out and in the tank several times, it fixes. I follow all maintenance suggestions for replacing rollers and filters, and I have already replaced both two times, but I can’t say that after replacement, it works better.

Even though the suction power is 17000 Pa, three rollers could be better at scrubbing. The quality of wet cleaning is much better with detergent, which is added to the detergent cartridge. I use liquid dish soap; it is pretty good for shining floors. I definitely can suggest this model, especially at a discount; about $500 is too expensive.

I purchased this model Tineco Floor One S5 on Black Friday but could not use it properly. I read your review, which promised good dry and wet cleaning results. I chose it between Roborock Dayd because it is lighter weight and True HEPA filter. I do not have pets or kids, so I do not need a dual brush roller system; a single brush roller seemed enough for me. The most appreciated feature should be a hand vac mode to clean furniture and my car. However, what did I receive?
I received a broken model. The LED display with iLoop smart sensor came broken. Even though the battery was fully charged, my display did not show any status, and there was no button to turn it on. Without this display, I can’t check the cleaning status, battery and use the cleaner properly. I was able to connect the cleaner with the app, but it still can’t work. Unfortunately, I can’t comment on any other features, such as roller brushers, suction power, or containers.
I contacted Tineco support via ticket, where I told them about my problem. I waited a week for the solution, and they suggested changing the cleaner. I have sent my broken piece, but I am still waiting for a new model to come. I do understand that the display was broken during transportation, but the packing should be improved to avoid such problems! After a long wait, I give only three starts, but the vacuum cleaner looks very convenient and pleasant.

Thank you for your comparison. I was choosing between these two models, Roborock Dyad and Tineco S5, and it was very helpful. I wanted to replace my Dyson Cyclone V10 as it was only a dry vacuum cleaner, but it did an outstanding job collecting mess after my two golden retrievers. I have chosen the Tineco S5 because its smart iLoop sensor automatically detects how much debris is on the floor. I like the color changing from red to blue. Another nice feature is the high water recovery rate; even though it has a large clean water tank – 0.8 L, I do not fill it every time, it is sufficient for 2-3 cleaning procedures.
It has an ergonomic design with a nice handle; it has a rotating cleaning head that allows you to clean corners. I can clean the stairs with him from one side to another! The only problem I have with this model is the regular clogging of rollers and dirty water pipes because of the hair. But honestly, I have the same with Dyson and my Roomba robot previously. All clogs are easily removed, and all parts are connected with a click, so no worries. To clean the rollers, the maintenance brush can be used (from the package), but I also can use scissors.
I would really appreciate it if this model costs $300, not more, but you may catch some coupons or discounts. All 2-in-1 cleaners (for wet and dry cleaning) cost about $500, which is a reasonable price. I recommend this model after half a year of usage, as I had no significant issues with it.

It's not often that products live up to the hype, but the S5 is an exception. Even with a regularly maintained clean household, the S5 surprised me with how much additional dirt it managed to pick up. Despite my routine of vacuuming daily and steam mopping once or twice a week, the S5 left me speechless. I was shocked to see the dirty water tank filled with brown mucky water after its maiden run, especially since I had steam mopped the night before. From that moment, I knew the S5 was worth every penny. I've been using it daily since its arrival, and it consistently delivers stellar results.

A few tips for those planning to purchase:

• Start with vacuuming: The S5 is not meant to replace a dedicated vacuum. Consider it a power mop, washing the floors after you've picked up large debris. The filter cleaning requires hands-on involvement, so you'll want to pick up any nasty chunks before the S5 hits the floor.
• Water Usage: For my 1800 sq. ft. LVP floors, about 1.5 tanks of clean water are needed per wash. Remember, cleaning the floors daily is part of my routine, so this is merely a maintenance wash, but refills might be required during the process.
• Soap Selection: You can use any low-foaming detergent of your choice. I personally used Tide (sparingly!) which caused minor sensor issues, but that was likely due to excessive foam.
• Regular Cleaning: After each use, take a few seconds to clean the S5 components, including the roller brush and the cover. It's a simple process that ensures longevity.
• Stairs: The S5 shuts off when placed upright, so to clean stairs, my technique is to wash half a step at a time - one half on the way up, and the other half on the way down.

There are some minor complaints, though:

• 1) Rapid backward movements can leave faint streaks on the floor, but this can be avoided by always moving the vacuum forward and overlapping backward strokes.
• 2) The water tank does require frequent refilling, slightly inconvenient but manageable.
• 3) The self-clean cycle requires 10% battery and a half-full clean water tank. It's a minor concern and easy to address.
• 4) The filter cleaning requires handling the dirt directly. It's not the most pleasant task but can be easily rinsed in the sink.
• 5) The S5 doesn't lie flat enough to slide under furniture, which could be a bit limiting for those who like thorough under-furniture cleaning.

Despite these minor issues, I am over the moon with the S5. It's an upgrade in all the right places, including ease of cleaning its components, a larger water tank, and better edge cleaning with its roller brush. My only regret is not making this purchase sooner.